Telecom: BCE chief warns Ottawa to tread carefully on foreign-ownership reforms

By Jamie Sturgeon | National Post - CBC.ca | May 18, 2010

George Cope, chief executive of BCE Inc., cautioned yesterday that government should carefully weigh a decision to change or scrap foreign-ownership restrictions in the telecommunications sector, an area of the economy he says is already flush with investment.

This follows comments last week from Industry Minister Tony Clement further suggesting Ottawa is moving toward a policy shift to promote competition.

At a lunch speech in Toronto, the CEO of the country’s largest communications company said the Canadian market has become highly competitive in the two years since he took over, forcing BCE’s Bell Canada to pump $6-billion into new wireless and wireline upgrades through 2010 to stay ahead.

He pointed to Bell’s new, multibillion-dollar 3G+ wireless network jointly built with rival Telus Corp. as an example of how domestic needs are being met, and warned that allowing in firms from the U.S. and elsewhere may hinder future advancements.

“Do you think Summerside, P.E.I., would come up before Chicago? Not going to happen,” he said. “It happened in this case. So let’s be very, very careful about what we’re trying to solve in Canadian telecom rules because the investment is actually working.”

The network blankets 93% of the country.

Mr. Clement told a special parliamentary committee last week that restrictions could be lifted on the telecom sector by allowing key content assets owned by the biggest providers like Bell and Rogers Communications Inc. to remain in Canadian hands, while opening up distribution and network assets to foreign ownership.

The comments follow a pledge in the Throne Speech in March to liberalize the sector. “Our government will open Canada’s doors further to venture capital and to foreign investment in key sectors, including the satellite and telecommunications industries, giving Canadian firms access to the funds and expertise they need,” Gov. Gen. Michaëlle Jean said at the time.

Ottawa’s move stems from two federal blue-ribbon reports completed in 2006 and 2008, that call for a relaxing of the rules as a way to spur more investment in economically important communications service.

This year however has seen three new entrants into the wireless market, in Wind Mobile, Mobilicity and Public Mobile, with cable giants Videotron Ltee. and Shaw Communications Inc. are on their way with wireless in Quebec and Western Canada.

Competition in broadband is also heating up as Bell and Telus Corp. invest billions this year overlaying copper networks with fibre, bringing alternatives to rival services provided by Rogers and Shaw. “What problems are we trying to solve, what’s the objective?” Mr. Cope said.

Still, the industry, especially in wireless, remains dominated by Bell, Rogers and Telus.

Some analysts suggest that without consolidation or access to more foreign capital (through a change in policy), the young startups face near-certain failure and a retrenchment in services in the market.

jasturgeon@nationalpost.com